Published December 19, 2018
NORMAN, Okla. — The Native American Journalists
Association (NAJA) issued the following statement after National Public
Radio broadcast and published “Native American Adoption Law Challenged
As Racially Biased” - an inaccurate and imprecise story about an Indian
Child Welfare Act (ICWA) custody case:
NPR violated its ethics policy by failing to thoroughly fact check its
reporting and allowing racist language and views on air unchallenged.
“Native American Adoption Law Challenged As Racially Biased” by Wade
Goodwyn contains multiple factual inaccuracies, lacks context, and
propagates racist language and ideas.
Goodwyn says "It turned out that Mason's mother - and therefore - Mason,
was part Indian." This is a misleading and incorrect statement: The
child's mother is a tribal citizen, therefore the child is also a tribal
citizen. This designation is foundational to federal Indian law. To
frame it otherwise is inaccurate and irresponsible, especially given the
sensitivity owed to children involved in ICWA cases. Goodwyn also
discloses the identity of a child involved in adoption proceedings – a
violation of their safety and privacy.
Goodwyn uses a quote from the child’s adoptive parent: "Mason didn't
even look Indian in the least regards." This is deceptive and
racially-coded language that defines the child's identity by physical
appearance or skin color. These types of depictions of Native people are
blatantly racist and should have been addressed by editors before
publication and in the story. In ICWA cases, the child’s identity is
based on a political connection to a sovereign nation, and is not based
on racial identifiers. This framing runs counter to NPR’s policy of
respect and accuracy.
The Goldwater Institute's Timothy Sandefur, who was chosen as a primary
source, provided a misleading argument that ICWA is a matter of race,
not of citizenship. This is disinformation often raised by groups that
seek to diminish and destroy the political identity of Indigenous
peoples and the sovereign status of tribal nations. By airing these
views nationally, NPR has provided a megaphone for anti-Indian ideas and
a platform for racism against Native people. As per NPR ethics,
reporters should check sources’ "facts," as advocates can skew the
context of the story.
NPR has an ethical obligation to report these views in their social and
political context but must also be committed to reporting these ideas
responsibly. The network’s ethics policy makes this clear in numerous
ways, and NAJA urges NPR to immediately correct the story. NPR should
also review its policies and personnel that allowed an unchecked
platform for racist ideas that propagate hostility and racism toward
Indigenous people.
It is the position of NAJA that NPR is in violation of its own ethics
policies by failing to conduct due diligence before publication. The
network continues to suffer missteps and stereotypical coverage of
Native communities, and NAJA has repeatedly offered free cultural
competency and ethics training to NPR staff and editors in the past with
no response. However, the offer remains and NAJA would be happy to work
with NPR to facilitate more accurate, and ethical, journalism.
NAJA is sponsoring an Indian Child Welfare Act reporting symposium at the University of Oklahoma. Learn more here.
 |
NPR Airs Inaccurate Story about Indian Child Welfare Act Custody Caseby Native News Online Staff |
No comments:
Post a Comment
Please: Share your reaction, your thoughts, and your opinions. Be passionate, be unapologetic. Offensive remarks will not be published. We are getting more and more spam. Comments will be monitored.
Use the comment form at the bottom of this website which is private and sent direct to Trace.